Reconsideration

  • ICANN feeds troll, refuses to censor “rip-off” web site

    … ICANN’s board has rejected a formal demand that it “take down” the web site RipoffReport.com in what is possibly the strangest Request for Reconsideration case it has considered to date. The almost 20-year-old site hosts reports from consumers about what they consider to be “rip-offs”. It’s seen its fair share of controversy and legal action…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 14 readers -
  • Could ICANN reject Verisign’s $135m .web bid?

    … ICANN is looking into demands for it to throw out Verisign’s covert $135 million winning bid for the highly prized .web gTLD. ICANN last week told the judge hearing Donuts’ .web-related lawsuit that it is “currently in the process of investigating certain of the issues raised” by Donuts through its “internal accountability mechanisms”. Donuts…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 17 readers -
  • .hotel losers gang up to threaten ICANN with legal bills

    …. HTLD won a controversial Community Priority Evaluation in 2014, effectively eliminating all rival applicants, but that decision was challenged in an IRP that ICANN ultimately won. The other applicants think HTLD basically cobbled together a bogus “community” in order to “game” the CPE process and avoid an expensive auction. Since the IRP…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 19 readers -
  • Spurned applicant crowd-funding to fight ICANN for .gay gTLD

    … The community-driven applicant for .gay is attempting to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars via crowd-funding to challenge a series of adverse decisions that look set to lock it out of running the gTLD. Alongside the fundraising, dotgay LLC has launched an extraordinary broadside at its frustrators, accusing ICANN of “discrimination…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 26 readers -
  • Registries rebel against ICANN’s Whois upgrade decree

    … Registry operators are challenging an ICANN decision to force them to launch a new Whois-style service, saying it will cost them too much money. The Registries Stakeholder Group has filed a Request for Reconsideration — a low-level appeal — of a decision asking them to launch RDAP services to complement their existing Whois. RDAP…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 7 readers -
  • dotgay loses third .gay appeal

    … Death warrant or portent of impending legal action? dotgay LLC has lost its third attempt to get ICANN to reconsider tossing its application for community priority status in the fight for the .gay gTLD. According to ICANN, on Sunday its Board Governance Committee threw out dotgay’s third Request for Reconsideration, an attempt to give…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 14 readers -
  • “We’re not homophobic!” ICANN pleads as it throws out .gay appeal

    … ICANN has refused dotgay LLC’s latest appeal against adverse .gay decisions, and has taken the unusual step of preemptively defending itself against probably inevitable accusations from gay right groups. On Monday, the Board Governance Committee threw out dotgay’s Request for Reconsideration, in which the company had asked for a third crack…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 20 readers -
  • Odd-couple coalition wants URS deleted from legacy gTLD contracts

    … and the Non-Commercial Stakeholders Group put their names to a Request for Reconsideration filed with ICANN yesterday. The Internet Commerce Association, a member of the BC, filed a separate RfR asking for the same thing yesterday too. These groups believe that ICANN contracting staff are trying to create consensus policy by the back door, from the top…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 7 readers -
  • Booking.com uses .africa precedent to challenge .hotels ruling

    … Similarity Review panel, part of the new gTLD evaluation process, ruled that they cannot. They’re just too similar — in standard browser sans-serif fonts they can be indistinguishable — and would likely lead to user confusion, the panel decided in February 2013. Booking.com challenged this decision with a Request for Reconsideration, which was dismissed…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 5 readers -
  • .gay is gay enough after all? ICANN overturns community panel decision

    … of international equal rights and gay community organizations. dotgay filed a Request for Reconsideration, ICANN’s cheapest but least reliable form of appeal, and today found out it actually won. ICANN’s Board Governance Committee, which handles the RfR process, this week ruled (pdf): The BGC concludes that, upon investigation of Requester’s…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 10 readers -
  • ICANN overturns new gTLD objection decision!

    … ICANN has overturned a Community Objection decision, allowing a .med new gTLD applicant back into the game, after a Request for Reconsideration from the applicant. It’s the first time ICANN has overruled an objection panel during the new gTLD program and the first time in over a decade any RfR of substance has been accepted by the ICANN board…

    Kevin Murphy/ DomainIncite- 12 readers -